Understanding The Difference Between Rebrand and Brand Refresh

What is Rebranding?

Rebranding involves a fundamental change in your company's identity. It's not just about updating your logo; it's about reshaping how your audience perceives your business. The goal is to create a new and differentiated brand identity in the minds of consumers, investors, prospects, competitors, employees, and the general public.

An example of our rebranding work is the rebranding of Paxo Finance to WeFi. This comprehensive rebrand involved creating a new name, logo, colour palette, and visual language that better reflected the company's ingenious approach to decentralized finance. The strategic visual overhaul effectively repositioned the company in the competitive DeFi landscape

According to a survey by Lucidpress, 32% of respondents reported that consistent branding across all marketing channels increased revenue by 20% or more. Hence, rebranding could be risky for your business. Enter Brand Refresh!

What is Brand Refresh?

A brand refresh is like giving your brand a facelift. It involves updating visual elements and messaging to stay current without changing the core identity. A brand refresh can energize a company's image, address minor inconsistencies, and adapt to evolving market trends without the dramatic overhaul associated with rebranding.

Mastercard's brand refresh in 2016 is an excellent example of updating a visual identity while maintaining core brand recognition. The company simplified its iconic interlocking circles logo, removing the comb effect in the overlap and later removing the wordmark below the symbol. This refresh maintained Mastercard's essential visual elements while adapting to digital environments and creating a cleaner, more versatile look. The update allowed Mastercard to appear more contemporary and adaptable to various digital platforms without losing its established brand equity, demonstrating how a thoughtful refresh can modernize a brand while preserving its iconic status.

Research by Edelman shows that 81% of consumers need to be able to trust the brand to buy from them, making a well-executed refresh crucial for maintaining that trust.

Key Differences Between Rebranding & Brand Refresh

1. Scope: Rebranding is comprehensive, involving a complete overhaul of a company's identity, including its name, logo, messaging, and often its core values or mission. On the other hand, a brand refresh is more targeted, focusing on updating specific visual elements or messaging while maintaining the overall brand identity.
2. Timeline: Rebranding typically takes longer and requires more resources, often involving extensive market research, stakeholder engagement, and a phased rollout plan.

A brand refresh can be implemented more quickly, with fewer resources, as it involves tweaking existing elements rather than creating entirely new ones.3. Risk: Rebranding carries higher risks but potentially greater rewards, as it can significantly impact customer perception and loyalty. While it offers the opportunity for dramatic positive change, it also risks alienating existing customers if executed poorly.

A brand refresh generally poses lower risks, enhancing brand relevance without disrupting established brand equity.

When Should You Consider Rebranding?

1. Significant company changes (mergers, acquisitions): When major structural changes occur, rebranding becomes necessary, as it helps to unify the new entity and communicate its combined strengths to stakeholders.
2. Outdated brand image: When your brand no longer resonates with your target audience or reflects current market trends, rebranding can revitalize your company's image and relevance.
3. Entering new markets or expanding product lines: Rebranding can help position your company effectively in new markets or accommodate an expanded range of products or services your current brand identity doesn't adequately represent.
4. Reputation issues: If negative associations or controversies have tarnished your brand, rebranding can be a strategic move to distance the company from past issues and rebuild trust with consumers.

Example: Apple's 1997 rebrand from Apple Computer to Apple Inc. paved the way for their expansion beyond computers, leading to revolutionary products like the iPhone and iPad.

When Should You Consider a Brand Refresh?

1. Minor updates needed to stay current: A brand refresh is appropriate when your brand's visual elements or messaging need subtle updates to remain relevant and appealing in the current market landscape.
2. Expanding target audience within the same market: When aiming to attract a broader or slightly different audience segment without fundamentally changing your market position, a brand refresh can help adjust your appeal while maintaining brand recognition.
3. Aligning with new company values without changing core identity: If your company has evolved its values or mission slightly, a brand refresh can help communicate these changes while preserving the essence of your established brand identity.

Example: Starbucks' gradual logo evolution, eventually dropping the "Starbucks Coffee" text while maintaining the recognizable siren image, demonstrates a successful brand refresh.

How to Decide Between Rebrand or Refresh?

1. Conduct a Brand Audit
‍Evaluate your current brand position, customer perception, and market standing. A comprehensive review can reveal whether you need a complete overhaul or a touch-up.

2. Consider the 7-Year Rule
‍Many experts suggest evaluating your brand every 7-10 years. While not a strict rule, this is a good benchmark for assessing its relevance.

3. Apply the IDEA Framework

1. Identify your brand's current position
2. Determine where you want to be
3. Evaluate the gap between the current and desired position
4. Act on insights to close the gap

4. Assess Digital Presence
How well does your brand translate across online platforms in today's digital-first world? If it's struggling, a rebrand might be necessary.

5. Analyze Competitive Differentiation
‍Are you becoming indistinguishable from competitors? This could signal the need for a rebrand to stand out.

Key Takeaway

The decision between rebranding and a brand refresh is more than one-size-fits-all. It depends on your company's unique situation, goals, and market position. Whether you're a tech startup looking to make a splash or an established B2B company aiming to stay relevant, aligning your branding strategy with your business objectives is key.

At Spacekayak, we specialize in helping companies in AI, SaaS, Web3, and Fintech navigate these crucial branding decisions. Ready to explore whether your business needs a rebrand or a refresh? Let's chat about how we can elevate your brand to new heights.

‍